Best Cars for Teens

Getting Started

Picking out the first car for a teenager isn’t just about matching a vehicle with personality—it’s about balancing safety, budget, and practicality. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) and Consumer Reports have teamed up to help ease this choice by crafting a list of recommended vehicles that emphasize safety and value.

Compact Choices

Compact cars are highly favored for first-time drivers due to their maneuverability and efficiency. Leading the pack is the 2017-2019 Toyota Corolla, a model known for its reliability with an estimated value of around $9,500. Those looking into hybrids may consider the 2019-2022 Honda Insight, offering impressive fuel economy at about 55 mpg city and with a Kelley Blue Book value of $11,600.

If a bit more fun behind the wheel is a priority without straying into sports car territory, the 2019-present Mazda3 hatchback is worth checking out. Its spirited handling with 186 horsepower comes at an estimated price of $12,100, which adds up to a lively yet safe experience.

Midsize Marvels

Midsize cars often step up when space needs grow or the vehicle doubles as a family car. The 2018-present Toyota Camry leads in this category, with prices starting from $13,100 and delivering an ideal balance between comfort and reliability. For a touch of elegance, the Mazda6 (2019-2021) offers a more premium feel with a slightly higher price of $14,000.

Another solid choice is the 2020-present Subaru Legacy, priced at approximately $15,700. Known for its standard all-wheel drive, it’s a solid companion for unpredictable weather, ensuring traction and stability when needed most.

Large and In Charge

Luxury doesn’t have to be out of reach for new drivers. The Genesis G80 (2017-2020) comes with modern comforts and a safety rating that lives up to its $12,200 price tag. The slightly bigger Genesis G90, valued at $12,400, enhances the luxury experience without hitting the bank too hard.

The Acura RLX (2018-2020) steps in with a host of driver-assistance features such as adaptive cruise control and emergency braking, all at a KBB-estimated price of $16,700. It provides a blend of performance and luxury, securing a spot on the list of worthy contenders.

Small SUV Picks

Small SUVs bring an appealing blend of visibility and space. The 2019-present BMW X2 offers a taste of luxury for around $12,200, though it might bring heftier maintenance and insurance costs. For a more budget-friendly option, the 2020-2021 Mazda CX-3, priced at about $12,900, is a compact SUV that doesn’t compromise on drivability.

The Subaru Forester (2019-present), valued at $13,000, stands out due to its dependable all-wheel drive and safety credentials, making it a logical choice for peace of mind on the road.

Midsize SUV Options

When more room is needed, midsize SUVs prove their worth. The 2017-2020 Acura MDX combines premium quality with a competitive price of $13,100, inheriting reliability from its Honda roots. For those seeking trust-inspiring safety, the 2018-or-newer Volvo XC90, priced at about $14,600, caters to families wanting more seats and security.

The 2019-present Lexus NX, offered at $14,900, introduces buyers to Lexus reliability and luxury, rounding out a promising lineup for any young driver ready to hit the road.

Final Thoughts

Finding the right car for a young driver is a delicate balancing act between numerous factors. The IIHS staff suggests these carefully selected vehicles cater to both safety and cost-effectiveness. These choices span various categories and budgets, ensuring parents and teens alike can find a model that aligns with their needs. For further options, the IIHS website holds additional recommendations, providing plenty of pathways to finding the right first car.